No promotions whatsoever for men working at Siemens. No matter how hard working, no matter how qualified. Until Siemens’ "voluntary" women quota of 20% is reached. A high ranking Engineer at Siemens told me this in summer 2012.
It does not matter than only 6% of machine and car engineers in Germany are female. It does not matter that women work shorter hours, interrupt their career, and in general choose health and comfort over maximum financial benefits (Warren Farrell).
It is preposterous that political correctness brainwashed our politicians end the general population to think that
- women earn 70% of a man’s salary for the SAME work. And businesses stubbornly refuse to be more profitable. Businesses rather forego the financial benefits of hiring and promoting women at 70% of men’s salary. Profit-oriented businesses prefer to pay`40% more to an equally qualified man, just out of spite, so the old boy’s network can discriminate against women. And not one single company has figured out that by hiring only low paid women they could annihilate the competition that stupidly hires expensive men at their higher salary. (see wage gap and Warren Farrell)
- So it is only logical that German labor minister van der Leyen states that only gender diverse companies can compete against international competition. Thus the government has to make rules to force businesses to do more rational hiring decisions, and to become more profitable and successful. Business on its own would rather incur losses then hire equally or higher qualified women. Preposterous.
- EU plans tough quotas to put women in the boardroom. Are politicians too stupid to understand the wage gap lie statistics?
I can only imagine the effect on men’s morale. Imagine highly qualified engineer at Siemens seeing how the rare women engineer, with lower qualification and much less seniority and work experience, gets promoted to the male engineer’s level, and then promoted again to become his superior. Without merit and qualification. All this while the man’s position and salary remains the same.
The European Community is finalizing binding laws to mandate quotas for women.The quotas are meant to force companies to institute flexible work hours and better conciliation of work and family life. Only enforced quotas will force companies to hire and promote women [summarized from 2]
In Germany, the only discussion is if there should be mandatory 40% quotas for women, or if companies were to set their own binding goals for women quotas. Nobody thinks that companies should make their own rational decisions based on merit, on qualification, eagerness to work, ambition. Not on any quotas.
German Family Minister Kristina Schroeder (also CDU), on the other hand, favors a so-called flexi rate. This requires a company to set their own quota levels which they are required to fulfill.
CDU party Economic Council shares Schröder’s position ". Rigid quotas for women put the industry in Germany into unnecessary restraints When only six percent of the engineering and automotive engineers are women, then the automotive and engineering industries can not reach the discussed 40 percent of women in executive bodies" said Kurt J. Lau, spokesman for the council, told SPIEGEL ONLINE. The FDP party leadership is against a rigid quota for women. 2
No excuses here that this will be good for companies. When urgent emergency repairs have to be made, the boss is on family friendly work hours. And the subordinates are demoralized, why should they work overtime when the boss is on 35 hour flex time week.
Under debate [in Germany] is a law, that requires that at large companies by 2018 20 per cent of members of supervisory and management boards have to be women. Five years later, the percentage is to rise to 40 percent 3
We are waiting for law proposals, that 40% of elementary school teachers be male, 40 % of garbage collectors and construction helpers be women, and 40% of prisoners be female.
German minister Ursula van der Leyen recently authored the insane comment, that German industry needs women leaders in order to stay competitive world wide. In other words, were it not for big brother government to force enterprise to promote women, companies would act against their own interest and self-destructively would hire men.
Milton Friedman – Case Against Equal Pay for Equal Work
Immortal Milton Friedman. We have "progressed" (negatively) since.
Now employers cannot escape equal pay laws by not employing members of the less productive group. Now employers are obliged to hire or promote people into high ranking positions, no matter if they don’t consider them apt for the job, or not optimal for the job. They get promoted just because of their sexual organs (= because they have a vagina). And men at Siemens, deserving of promotion, will get stiffed and passed up, until enough women passed them up to higher pay levels.
Fear of punishing law suits are also a motive for companies to hire too many "disadvantaged" group members.
There is also a video by Friedman how he explains how discrimination, how pay gap are good for social justice. Because with a pay gap, the person who discriminates Is being punished, by having to pay a higher salary.
Of course, in today’s reality this does not happen, because in reality the pay gap is bogus.
The Right to Discriminate
Questions to the readers:
- where are web links to describe such policies? I tried to google for female quotas at Siemens, did not find anything.
5 thoughts on “Promotion stop for men at Siemens to achieve "voluntary" women quota”
There is even less mentioning that the presence of women makes men lose their freedom, it obliges men to watch their tongue and talk only in socially accepted ways, in order to avoid harassment charges. No more “inappropriate” jokes, … Who remembers the 70ies, when car repair shops could have pinup photos on the wall?
It is sad to see that there is no mentioning of Warren Farrel’s list of reasons why quotas are injustice against men (and women who really earn their place through hard work); The tone is quite clear, that everyone agrees that quotas are good and necessary.
This is idiotic behaviour which will harm Siemens, apart from being morally wrong.
Great post HS. Gender and racial quotas are a big part of why the Western world is going downhill and will be overtaken by Asia. I suppose, if the entire world gets the quota disease, we can all still limp along, but our quality of life will ultimately suffer.